The AI future does not contain published books.
Not a day goes by without someone asking on one writing site or other – what about using AI in writing your books? I’m not an expert on AI but as a working software engineer and a science fiction writer I might be able to make some guesses. And my guess is that AI is going to make authors redundant. More than that – it’s going to redefine publishing at a fundamental level.
First of all it’s important to understand that AI is still in its infancy. Amazing things are being done and great strides being taken in the field of neural network learning, algorithmic thinking and pattern recognition and adaptation. Anyone who’s currently taking solace in the thought that AI-written art is easily identifiable, that AI text is flat and uninspired, that an AI cannot produce a good piece of illustration or music or writing – is short-sighted at best and wilfully ignorant at worst.
I have, in my box of music composition tools, an app that generates brand new musical phrases and lines. This is not modern AI as we know it; the musical lines are not copied from other successful musical pieces, they’re generated at random using a few rules. They all have a level of musicality to them: they’re in the key and metre defined by the original parameters. But more often than not the results are boring or unsatisfying. The (human) user is expected to curate the resulting output and find the bits that work and the ones that don’t.
But there are other tools that can take a line of music and analyse its structure and its modulation and identify where simple changes will improve the listenability.
There are tools that can take a line of music are build a complex set of instrumentation around it.
There are tools that will use notation to simulate real instruments including breaths, string resonance, hammer-offs and every other minute audio trace of a a live performance. Even consumer-level digital musical instruments these days approach being impossible to differentiate from their analogue analogues.
There are now convincing automated tools to take text and render it into spoken (or sung) speech.
If we haven’t yet reached the point where a computer could, with no human interaction at all, produce a professional piece of music that real humans would pay to listen to – then we’re not far off it. And written long-form text is not far behind.
The bet that we will never be able to systematise the foundations of a novel is a foolish one. Whole university courses are taught on the structure of literature, the parameters of relatable and memorable characters, plot archetypes, stylistic approaches to language. What can be taught can be programmed. Combine that with a vast and daily-increasing online store of writing available to serve as a model and the source material for AI to sift and recombine, and it’s easy to see that there is nothing standing in the way of AI writing work that is – at the very least – competent.
Which brings us to the final hurdle: human preference. Music, and art, and literature, covers a vast spectrum of experience. What appeals to one reader will not be appropriate for another. You might love books that spend minimal time on establishing and developing character, so long as the plot is thrilling. Someone else reads books that consist entirely of a character going through their daily life with not an explosion in sight. AI can produce both of these books.
In the current state of AI, where producing a decent output requires some human intervention to set the parameters and help shape the output, it’s a numbers game. AI-written novels will be in the genres and archetypes that can gather the most clicks and eyeballs and purchases. But this is a temporary situation. This point in time will only last – maybe a few years. By 2030, by my guess, the situation will be quite different.
Right now you, as a reader, have your favourite books. You have your preferred genre. You know what you like in a book. Sometimes Amazon makes a recommendation that astonishes you because it’s so perfectly what you like, it’s as if it could have been written just for you.
This is what Amazon does: it looks at the millions of books published each year, and it analyses them for character and plot and genre, and it combines this data with what other readers have thought and said, and what each of those readers likes, and it works out what you like, and it pushes those works at you it thinks you are most likely to enjoy.
But in the very near future, the books it sends you won’t be written by real people. They’ll be written by AI. To suit your personal tastes. Based on the algorithms. And they’ll be perfect for you. Written just for you. And when you finish reading one, the next one will be only five minutes away. An unlimited, never-ending stream of perfectly-tailored narratives to keep you entertained as long as you have eyes and a will to read. (Or maybe ears, as the current trend of audiobooks continues.)
Will there be a human author’s name attached to these books? There will be at first. These will be novels by an author supervising the AI. Then will come the AI novels written in the same series but without the author’s direct involvement. But the end game will omit an author, and most readers won’t miss it. There won’t be authors any longer. Individual authors like me won’t be selling books, because the AIs that generate the books will be from Microsoft or Apple or Disney and these companies don’t like sharing with individual creators.
Will there still be authors? Perhaps a few. But writing a good book takes a lot of time and effort. Right now authors write in the hopes that they’ll make it big, knowing that most of them won’t. It’s a time investment and a gamble and the only people who can do it are those who either are driven to write almost as strongly as to eat, or those who have the leisure time to engage in a hobby. When the odds of getting people to read your story drop to near zero – when a reader has a choice between a brand new novel written just for their individual tastes costing practically nothing, and an author’s real book that took them a year to write and edit and won’t be exactly to the reader’s taste – there won’t be a market. There won’t be a return for the time investment. Writing a book will be a hobby and getting more than a few people to read it no more than a pipe dream. It’s already hard to promote a new self-published book amongst the ocean of other books out there. By the time AI is mature, I suspect it will be impossible.
Is this a future we want? Authors don’t want it. But authors and readers are at odds. It’s in the reader’s interest to have brand new, customised for their own tastes, works available at pittance costs. It’s in the big publishers’ interest to deliver those works. It’s in the writers’ interest to have a mass audience starved for content and willing to pay a moderate amount for it. Writers aren’t going to win out of that equation.
Even those authors currently posting questions about what about using AI to write your book don’t want it. Many of these questioners are looking for a way to shortcut the Work.
What is the Work? For an author, the Work is reading widely to stock the database of ideas and characters and set pieces and plot developments. AI already has a nearly unlimited stock of these resources; a human author can only read and experience so much content. The Work is learning the basics of language and then going beyond, so you can write like Hemingway or you can write like Tolkien, so you can develop your own unique narrative voice. The Work is developing your plot, and your character arcs, and your three-act structure; it’s writing your outline (if that’s what you do), your first draft, your rewrites, your edits.
Currently many authors are looking for ways to shortcut some of these steps. Maybe this author might love the initial writing, but rewriting and editing and proofreading are a chore. Surely AI can help with those steps? For another writer, the hurdle is coming up with the initial ideas, spinning out a decent plot. AI can help with that. Or maybe it’s the initial draft that’s hardest, getting the words down on the page before the fun bit of editing and rewriting can commence. AI can do that step too.
But AI can do all the steps. And when AI can do all the steps, the big boys step in to empower AI to do all the steps, and the authors looking for ways to bring a novel from concept to polished POD novel in a month won’t get a look in.
What can we do to avoid this dystopia?
There’s only one step in the writing and publishing environment that AI cannot automate out of existence: community. If the AI litapocalypse is all about creating unique content for each reader, there’ll be no Booktok; no book clubs, no author fan groups, no reader communities. These are the last line of defence against the AI.
I suspect we can’t hold off the future. Personalised novels for readers will happen. Perhaps some portion of the future might be reserved, though, for those who would call themselves Writers, in partnership with their communities of Readers.
So go and find your communities. Support the authors you love – not just through buying their books, but in talking about them to others. Share your thoughts on the latest novel you read on Facebook or Twitter (sorry, “X”) or even Myspace. And listen to other people’s recommendations about things to read, while you still have the opportunity to read something that wasn’t written just for you. Something you can share with other readers; an experience that’s as much about what the author wants to give you as it is about what you want to receive.
(Oh, and support this author by buying my book on Amazon. US or AU. No AIs were used in the making of this novel!)
Further reading:
https://aicontentfy.com/en/blog/future-of-creative-writing-with-ai-technology
“While the technology may be able to generate high-quality writing, it cannot replicate the creativity, empathy, and emotional depth that are the hallmarks of great literature.”
https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2023/05/generative-ai-novel-writing-experiment-stephen-marche/673997/
“The creator of meaningful literary AI art will be, in effect, a literary curator.”
https://medium.com/codex/future-of-ai-writing-ea1c6a4cc367
“However, machines will never be able to create truly original content — at least not yet. So don’t be afraid to use writing tools, but always remember to put a human touch on your content.”
What do you think? Is my outlook too pessimistic? Let’s discuss!





Kylie Chan’s fantasy novels – White Tiger, Red Phoenix, Black Jade and a bunch of other colours – are endemic to bookshops at present. I haven’t yet read any of Chan’s work but the novels all bear stunning covers and are, apparently, well-regarded, and it was only a matter of time before I caved into the pressure and bought one.